Finance · Checked November 3, 2026
NYC heat pump retrofit: Con Edison electric rate risk
A heat pump that replaces gas trades one utility bill for another. This page tests how much electricity can rise before a New York City retrofit stops paying off.
Heatpump Economics has no affiliation with, sponsorship from, or endorsement by any manufacturer, installer, lender, utility, aggregator, or program administrator named here.
The short answer
- In Con Edison territory, a heat pump that replaces a gas boiler is a bet that electricity prices will not outrun gas prices. Through 2028 the approved rate plan favors the heat pump, because gas heating bills are set to rise faster than electric bills.
- In this example the retrofit costs about $3,000 more after the rebate and saves about $416 in the first year once gas service is closed. On the approved plan, followed by 3% a year for both fuels, it comes out about $7,244 ahead over 15 years.
- The result turns negative if electricity rises more than about 6.8% a year after 2028 while gas rises 3%. Con Edison residential prices rose about 7.7% a year from 2021 to 2025, so a repeat of that pace would erase the gain.
- Keeping gas service for a stove gives up the gas minimum charge. With gas service kept, the break-even electric rise falls to about 2.5% a year, below the approved plan.
Electricity has risen faster than inflation
Con Edison’s average residential revenue per kWh rose from 27.3¢ in 2021 to 36.7¢ in 2025, according to its 2025 annual report. Its own historical average full-service rates show the New York City residential energy price, excluding the customer charge, at 29.52¢ in 2023, 33.45¢ in 2024 and 33.83¢ in 2025. Much of the rise came from delivery charges.
Con Edison residential price per kWh, actual and approved path
Average residential revenue per kWh sold, 2021–2025, then the approved total-bill increases for a 600 kWh customer.
Swipe to see the full chart →
What the approved rate plan does to each fuel
The Public Service Commission approved three-year electric and gas rate plans in January 2026 that run through December 2028 (PSC announcement). For a typical residential heating gas customer, the approved increases are larger than for electric customers in all three years, according to the PSC case description. The gas plan also funds replacement or abandonment of 80 miles of leak-prone main each year.
Approved yearly bill increases, electric vs gas heating
Electric SC 1 at 600 kWh a month and gas SC 3 Rate I heating at 100 therms a month.
Swipe to see the full chart →
Supply prices sit outside the rate plan. Con Edison’s winter bill outlook expects typical gas heating bills to rise 11.3% from last winter and typical NYC electric bills 7.2%. Year-to-year swings like these are why the analysis below tests price paths rather than one forecast.
Four electric price paths for the same home
The example is a one- or two-family home in Queens or Staten Island that heats with an 85% efficient gas boiler, uses about 700 therms a year for heat and cools with window units. A whole-home cold-climate heat pump costs about $20,000 before a $8,000 Con Edison Clean Heat rebate, compared with $9,000 for a new boiler. Rebate levels are covered in New York heat pump programs.
At a seasonal efficiency of 2.8, the heat pump needs about 6,226 kWh a year for heat. At 33.8¢ per kWh that is $2,104, against $1,960 for gas at about $2.80 per marginal therm built from the Con Edison gas rate summary and winter supply prices. On heating alone the two are close. The heat pump pulls ahead on more efficient cooling and on closing the gas account, which avoids the $34 monthly minimum charge.
Cumulative savings from the retrofit under four electric price paths
Gas service closed. Gas follows the approved plan, then rises 3% a year.
Swipe to see the full chart →
On the approved plan the retrofit pays back in about 6 years. At 5% a year after 2028 it ends about $3,631 ahead after 15 years. If electricity repeats the 2021–2025 pace from now on, the household ends about $7,492 behind.
How fast electricity can rise before the retrofit loses
Fifteen-year result against the electric price rise after 2028
Each line moves only the yearly electric increase after 2028. Positive values mean the heat pump comes out ahead.
Swipe to see the full chart →
The gap between the green and red lines is the gas minimum charge. Closing the account is worth more over 15 years than most equipment choices, but it requires electric cooking and water heating, whose costs are not counted here. If gas delivery costs rise faster as customers leave the system, the purple line shows the cushion grows: break-even moves to about 8.8% a year.
What protects the retrofit
Steady Use Rate
Con Edison’s demand-based Steady Use Rate charges on peak kW instead of every kWh. Enrolled heat pump customers saved $867 on average over a year, and first-year enrollees get a price guarantee. It is not modeled here.
Close the gas service
Avoiding the minimum charge is the largest single lever. It needs a plan for cooking and hot water, ideally at the same visit.
Higher seasonal efficiency
At a seasonal efficiency of 3.2 instead of 2.8, heating electricity falls by about 13%, which buys roughly another point of electric price rise.
Air sealing first
Every therm of heat not needed is a kWh not bought at future prices. Weatherization lowers exposure to both fuels.
Disadvantaged community level
The Con Edison rebate is higher in disadvantaged communities, which cuts the upfront gap and shortens payback.
Fixed-rate loan
A fixed loan payment does not hedge electricity, but it keeps one part of the monthly cost known. See mission-driven heat pump finance.
Questions to ask before committing money
- Would the Steady Use Rate or time-of-use rate cost less for the new load?
- What does the approved plan do to each fuel through 2028?
- How much of the gas bill is the minimum charge?
- What seasonal efficiency is the system rated for at New York temperatures?
- Does the design cover the whole home, or keep the boiler as backup?
- Is the electric panel adequate?
- Will cooking and hot water also move to electric?
- Does the rebate require removing the boiler?
- What does it cost to cap the gas line?
- How much would a 1-point faster electric rise cost over 15 years?
- Is there budget for a winter like 2025–26?
- Who pays for repairs after the warranty?
Method and caveats
The home uses 700 therms a year for space heat in an 85% boiler; the heat pump delivers the same heat at a seasonal efficiency of 2.8, or about 6,226 kWh. Cooling falls from 1,500 kWh with window units to 900 kWh. Maintenance is $250 a year for the heat pump and $200 for the boiler.
Electricity uses the 2025 NYC residential all-in energy price of 33.83¢ per kWh, which includes taxes but not the customer charge. Gas uses about $2.80 per therm for marginal heating use, built from the SC 3 Rate I base rate, monthly adjustments and winter supply prices; closing gas service avoids the $34 monthly minimum. Both fuels follow the approved 2026–2028 bill impacts, then the stated path.
Installed costs ($20,000 heat pump, $9,000 boiler) are assumptions, not quotes. Values are nominal and not discounted. This page is educational, not financial advice, and Heatpump Economics has no relationship with Con Edison.