Heat pump economics

Every Degree.
Every Dollar.

Heatpump Economics provides objective, data-driven tools for residential, commercial, and industrial heat pump decisions. We model equipment, installation, electricity, fuel, demand charges, maintenance, incentives, grid flexibility, and lifecycle value, so you can see whether a heat pump pays off against the system it replaces and which assumptions make it work.

Thermal console · one homeWinter peak event
Heat pump2.4 kWHOLDING 2°F SETBACK Heat PumpWater Heater0.0 kWCOASTING ON TANK Other loads1.1 kWLIGHTS · COOKING Grid3.5 kWPEAK IMPORT Outdoor air18°FCOLD EVENING HOMEPANEL
Indoor temp70.0°F
Tank temp140°F
Peak kWh shifted0.0
Clock 5:00 p.m. · event 5 to 8 p.m.

Illustrative only. A cold-climate heat pump pre-heats the home before a 5 to 8 p.m. winter peak event and then holds a 2°F setback, while a Heat Pump Water Heater coasts on its stored hot water. Together they move about 1.8 kW off the peak, roughly 5 kWh over three hours, with the home and tank drifting a few degrees.

●Customer types Residential · Commercial · Industrial ●Heat pump families modeled 24 ●Incumbent systems modeled 20 ●Utility lookup 50 states + DC ●Case studies 6 cities

Illustrative comparison

One home. Two systems.
Ten years of costs.

A heat pump decision is a comparison against a specific system, not against an average. This sample uses the figures from our Seattle case study: a 1,400 sq ft bungalow heated by electric baseboard, on Seattle City Light's rate of about 14.95¢/kWh.

Illustrative comparison 10-year total cost · Seattle, WA · 1,400 sq ft home
Heat pump

Ductless Mini-Split
Two zones, about 2 tons

$20,548

10-year cost

  • Equipment & install$6,750
  • Heating electricity$11,513
  • Cooling electricity$535
  • Maintenance$1,750
Incumbent

Electric Baseboard
Plus equivalent cooling

$28,322

10-year cost

  • Equipment & install$4,700
  • Heating electricity$21,553
  • Cooling electricity$569
  • Maintenance$1,500

Ten-year cost gap $7,774 lower for the heat pump

Sample figures from one case study, before incentives. Both systems run on the same electricity rate, so the gap comes from efficiency: the mini-split delivers roughly 2.2 units of heat per unit of electricity, baseboard exactly 1.

The crossover moment

When does the math flip?

A heat pump usually costs more to install than the system it replaces. It often costs less to run, especially against electric resistance heat, oil or propane. Somewhere along the ownership timeline, the cumulative cost lines can cross. In the Seattle sample above, they cross after about two years. Heatpump Economics calculates that crossover point for a specific climate, building and baseline system.

$30k$22.5k$15k$7.5k$0 Y0Y2Y4Y6Y8Y10 CROSSOVER · YEAR 2.1 Heat pump becomes cheaper Baseboard $28,322 Heat pump $20,548

Straight-line cumulative cost from the Seattle case study: install cost at year 0, then equal annual energy and maintenance costs, with no fuel-price change or discounting. Not every case crosses. In our Chicago case study, inexpensive Illinois gas keeps the furnace cheaper every year. The calculator computes the crossover for any ZIP code and baseline system.

The proposition

A heat pump moves heat.
The question is what that is worth.

Most heat pump calculators are built by manufacturers, utilities or industry groups, and the math tends to reflect who paid for it. A manufacturer calculator may assume best-case efficiency at mild temperatures. A gas-industry calculator may leave out the incentives that offset part of the installed cost.

Heatpump Economics is independent. We use current utility tariffs and U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) prices, model performance at local design temperatures using NEEP cold-climate listings and manufacturer data, and track incentive status as programs open, change and close. Beyond the bill, a heat pump can also provide grid flexibility: a thermostat or Heat Pump Water Heater enrolled in a demand response or virtual power plant (VPP) program can be paid to shift its load. We keep those program payments separate from energy savings.

No sales pitch. If the numbers say the existing gas furnace wins in a given climate, we say so.

Read the full methodology →

Four ways a heat pump pays

Same equipment. Four different business cases.

A heat pump's value depends on what it replaces and where it runs. Each case hinges on a different variable: the incumbent fuel, the cooling load, the rate design, or access to a grid program. Strong projects usually stack two or more.

01

Fuel switching

Replaces electric resistance, oil or propane heat with equipment that delivers two to four units of heat per unit of electricity.

Driven by the incumbent fuel price and climate

02

Heating plus cooling

One system replaces both a furnace and an air conditioner, so the comparison includes the AC that would otherwise be bought.

Driven by cooling load and equipment timing

03

Rate design

Seasonal, time-of-use and heat pump rates can lower the winter cost of every kWh, which often decides cold-climate cases.

Driven by the utility tariff

04

Grid flexibility

Smart thermostats and Heat Pump Water Heaters can enroll in demand response or virtual power plant (VPP) programs and be paid to shift load.

Driven by program access and payment rules

A Heat Pump Water Heater with a green status light in a basement utility roomEvery line item · one ledger

What's included

Every line item, accounted for.

A heat pump decision is a ledger: what the system costs to buy and run, set against what it replaces and the value it can realistically capture. Our calculators keep each line separate so you can see which ones carry the result.

  • Equipment, installation and electrical upgradesYou pay
  • Backup or auxiliary heat below the balance pointYou pay
  • Electricity or fuel to run itYou pay
  • Maintenance, repairs and financingYou pay
  • Avoided fuel and air conditioner costsOn the bill
  • State and utility rebatesOne-time
  • Demand response and VPP program paymentsProgram-specific
  • Comfort, humidity control and fuel-delivery independenceHard to price

How we model it →